Somehow, I keep ending up with books about "deconstruction" in my hands....
Deconstruction is the name given to the new movement where Christians suddenly feel like they've been lied to in some fundamental way and set out to tear down the faith they feel like they've been handed and seek to find their own way with God (with many, it must be said, deciding that perhaps there simply is no God at all and walking away into the "nones" - those with no religious affiliation).
For many entering the journey of deconstruction, the questions are legitimate. And let me be clear - God is not afraid of our questions.
It's important to ask why dynamics are at play in the faith that you've been taught - what your teachers believe, what shaped them, what shapes you, what defines the community you've been in, what power dynamics might be at play, what insecurities lie under the surface, what understandings seem fundamental and where they came from, and so on.
There's not a single one of us who is a neutral human being. Faith is never going to be objective; it wasn't meant to be. At least, the Christian faith wasn't meant to be.
In a worldview where our God desired to be in relationship with us from the very beginning, the Christian faith has always been meant to be personal. That is necessarily going to introduce some interesting dynamics into how we portray our faith to others.
The problem, I think, begins when we think that our questions are the first ones ever to be asked.
With every single book on deconstruction that I've read (to date), the question has been...how has this broken Christianity I've been taught about actually helped me to understand God?
What's happening is that the Christian story someone has been given comes up against a question in their life that it doesn't seem capable of answering. At least, not satisfactorily. So everyone seems to think that their question is the one that God wasn't ready for, that He doesn't have an answer for.
And then they go off searching for all the ways the Christianity they know isn't like them...and they usually come up with something about how it comes out of oppressive systems and was created by "white cisgender heterosexual males heavily invested in the patriarchy"...or some similar nonsense.
Hey, uhm, spoiler alert? There's not a single white guy in the Bible. So you can stop hating on Christianity for being the "white man's religion."
But see, this is exactly why the questions are important. Because there are things in the Bible that are either more or less emphasized depending on your cultural time and place. So those questions are important to ask.
What I don't see being asked are the more important questions - the questions that could answer the questions that are being asked.
See, a deconstructionist decides that the Christian faith they've been given is poisoned somehow, usually by white guys, and then literally every single thing that is ever said about God that fits into what they've conceived as the "white male Christianity" is automatically trash and anyone who speaks it is obviously brainwashed, uncritical, and detached from reality.
But what if they'd ask questions of their community instead of just about it? What if they'd start by talking to those white cisgender heterosexual white guys and finding out the depth of meaning that the God they know has for them? What if they were more interested in discovering the God who is personal...and not pretending there's some kind of thing as an objective Christianity?
I think we all have a lot to learn from Christians who we think are getting it wrong. I think if we'd start asking questions about their God, we might start learning some of it.
Maybe that's how I keep ending up with books about deconstruction in my hands...because I keep believing the folks asking these questions have something to teach me about the God they know.